SHOW DON’T TELL (mostly)

But how do I do it?

One of the first pieces of advice all new writers hear is “Show don’t tell”. But what does it mean? And how do you do it?

WHAT DOES IT MEAN?

Really, it’s about the difference between telling someone about an event and RECREATING that event on the page so that they too can experience what it was like to be there. How do we do this? By WRITING IN SCENES!

When we write in scenes we are, as much as is possible, translating experience into word pictures that a reader can see, hear, smell, feel and taste through their imaginations interacting with our words on the page. It’s the difference between telling someone, “I had a really rotten time at school. I was bullied,” and showing them by writing a scene of you being bullied at school so that they can walk in your shoes for a minute or two – so they feel the spit-ball land on the back of your head as you walk through the schoolgrounds, so they smell the rotten egg sandwiches the bully put in your locker, so they hear the taunts and feel the hurt inflicted. 

Photo by Mikhail Nilov on Pexels.com

HOW DO YOU DO IT?

Look through what you’ve written, whether it’s memoir or fiction it all works the same. Find a passage where you’re telling – don’t worry we all do it, even experienced writers have unwanted patches of telling in their first drafts – something that has potential for a scene. For example, “My father was a really great man”. Instead of telling us, SHOW US how he was great, in his own unique way. 

Write the scene of how he did you wrong, show us the good he did. Let us hear him speak, the things he said, the smell of him. Find a moment of a harsher side of him too, so he becomes more than a caricature of goodness. Develop the scene fully. Show us the conflict. Think of each scene as a little mini story painting a picture of the life you want to portray, the plot point you want to illustrate, the character you want us to understand.

Photo by Derick Makwasi on Pexels.com

Here’s an article on HOW TO WRITE A SCENE IN 6 EASY STEPS and another on WRITING CONCISE SCENES.

TELLING A LITTLE BIT

Though mostly it’s best to write predominantly in scenes, telling is also an important part of shaping and most especially grounding our stories. At the start of a scene for example you need to make sure the reader knows where and when they are in time and place and who the POV character is for the scene. Make sure you GROUND YOUR READER with a little bit of telling – it doesn’t have to be much, a sentence or two. 

For example: When I was seven years old, we lived on the banks of the Oxley Creek in a sixties fibro house my father had renovated himself, so all the doors and windows hung slightly awry. Then you can go into a scene set in that slightly crooked house.

Photo by Henry Han on Pexels.com

OR you can use telling to cover a large period of time when nothing much happened. Don’t feel that every single detail needs to be included in your story. Unless you’ve been poisoned, we really don’t care what you had for breakfast, or if your character has chestnut curls after a recent trip to the hairdresser – unless they’re disguising themselves on the run from police.

Instead, you can use a brief passage of telling to fill us in. For example: Three years later I was still on the run, but I was desperate to see my mother again. My sister had got a message to my hut on a Thai island. Mum was sick. I had to see her. No matter the risk. So I dyed my hair brown and curled it, padded myself with cushions, plastered my face in dark tan foundation and took the risk of getting on a flight back to my hometown. 

Photo by Fabian Wiktor on Pexels.com

READ widely in your genre of choice and mark out passages of telling between scenes. Can you spot them? Now have a look at your own project. Are you mainly telling? What sections might work well as scenes? 

Now WRITE THAT SCENE. Use the tips in my articles on writing scenes to help. Your writing will come alive on the page and your readers will feel as if they too are experiencing the story events, not just hearing about them.

GOOD LUCK! Let me know how you go!

Lots of love

Edwina xx

BEWARE INFO DUMPS! And How to Fix Them.

Photo by Tom Fisk on Pexels.com

You’ve started your story with a bang, like you’re supposed to. You’ve got a great hook, a killer first scene and everything is coming up roses, but then you start explaining. And explaining. Filling the reader in on every little detail they need to know about your protagonist, right from when and where they were born and their parents troubled histories, and their schooling and how they were bullied as kids and were jealous of their sisters and then started work, but that first job just wasn’t a right fit and… Twenty pages later, your story comes back to your exciting hook. But your reader has already left the building.

What you’ve just done is an INFO DUMP! So easy to fall into, trickier to get out of.

Photo by Filipe Delgado on Pexels.com

Info dumps come in many forms, and most writers have done one, at least once! They’re a first draft hazard, when we’re still figuring out who our characters are. But don’t worry, they can be fixed.

BACKSTORY DUMPS

Photo by Rodolfo Clix on Pexels.com

The first type of info dump that most writers fall into is the kind described above, a whole lot of information about the character, their formative years and family. This is important to know, as the writer. Not so much for the reader who’ll pick up key points about this background as they read the story that hooked them. Writers need to have a thorough knowledge of their characters, so we write about them and really get to know every detail in our first drafts. Info dumps also happen a lot in memoir, where perhaps the background information is more relevant. However, if you drop everything into one big pile, especially at the start of a story, the reader will turn away. 

You’ve grabbed them with the hook, and they want to keep reading that story, not some long-winded explanation of why the character is the way they are.

REMEDY

Photo by Chokniti Khongchum on Pexels.com

All your work has not been wasted. Use that information to drip feed to your readers on a “need to know” basis. Keep secrets about the past and reveal them in phrases or sentences around key plot points in the story that hooked your readers in the first place. You need to know everything because that will help you shape your characters’ actions, but let the reader infer most of the backstory, dropping in snippets where relevant or important.

And keep that big traumatic secret for as long as you can, ready to reveal when your character is at their lowest point.

RESEARCH DUMPS

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com

This dump occurs a lot in historical fiction or in memoirs where the author has gone down the rabbit hole of family history research right back to the 1600s! Now, it’s wonderful to have all this new knowledge, but when you dump it all on the reader in one big whammy, they’ll feel like they’re reading a textbook, not a narrative. So, even though you’re now the expert on a certain rare bee for example, don’t inflict the reader with page after page of everything you’ve learnt, no matter how interesting.

You’ve captured their attention with your great story hook, don’t let that fish wriggle off the line by expecting them to be as interested as you are in your pet research topic. 

REMEDY

Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels.com

Your job now is to seamlessly interweave the most vital and relevant information through your plot, setting and characters, to make it seem as if the research isn’t even there, but that the world you’ve created is real and accurate. Your research must be revealed through characters, settings and plot points that demonstrate the knowledge you’ve gained. Not in one big ugly dump, but in every specific detail you share about the time and place, and through the way characters act and interact.

DIALOGUE INFO DUMPS

Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels.com

Take either of the dump categories above and insert all the information into someone’s very long section of dialogue and you have a Dialogue Dump. Don’t do it. Ever. Or your reader will end up looking like the poor fellow in the photo!

Dialogue is a stylised form of expression more akin to poetry than actual conversation. It is always best kept brief, except of course for the occasional monologue, but don’t let even them run on too long.

REMEDY

Remove all dumps from dialogue and find another way to include only the most important information. If you need to have your characters explain their pasts for the sake of the plot, then give them a potent line or two but paraphrase the rest and cut back as much as you can while retaining meaning. If you’ve dumped a whole lot of plot information into a character’s speech, cut right back and reveal anything extra in another way.

Photo by Mia Stein on Pexels.com BEWARE THE INFO DUMP DRAGON!

So beware the info dump! By all means, let yourself go in your first draft and write as much as you like about every character’s past or the specialness of that bee, or the shoes they wore in 16th century Spain, just don’t let it slide into your second draft without serious consideration of how, where and why you insert it. If you’ve included over a paragraph or two of backstory or research details, you’ve gone too far. Cut back. Sometimes all you need is a phrase or a sentence or two.

I hope that helps you slay your Info Dump Dragons and write the very best book you can. Do let me know if you found this useful!

Write like the wind!

Lots of love,

Edwina xx